Astigmatism and cataract? A toric IOL can fix both
Schedule an examFind Eye Doctor
One thing that can prevent that from happening is residual astigmatism after surgery.
Astigmatism is very common before and after cataract surgery. Almost one in three people who are candidates for cataract surgery in the United States have at least 1.0 diopter (D) of astigmatism, which is enough to cause noticeably blurred vision without eyeglasses or contact lenses.
One study of refractive errors found that 29 percent of the U.S. population has between 1.0 and 2.0 D of astigmatism, 6.5 percent has between 2.0 and 3.0 D, and 2.2 percent has at least 3.0 D. These findings suggest nearly four out of 10 Americans have a significant amount of astigmatism.
In the past, intraocular lenses (IOLs) used in cataract surgery could not correct astigmatism. Some astigmatism could be corrected if the cataract surgeon chose to make incisions in the cornea during cataract surgery — a procedure called limbal relaxing incisions (LRI). Unfortunately, the LRI procedure can correct only limited amounts of astigmatism, and sometimes outcomes are unpredictable.
Thankfully, special intraocular lenses (called toric IOLs) have been developed to more predictably correct astigmatism during cataract surgery.
How Toric IOLs Work
Like toric soft contact lenses for astigmatism, toric IOLs have different powers in different meridians of the lens to correct the asymmetric power of the eye that is characteristic of astigmatism.
Cataract surgery with a toric lens implant (IOL) is essentially the same as cataract surgery with a conventional IOL, but with a couple of important differences.
Prior to surgery, measurements are taken to enable cataract surgeons to choose the most beneficial toric IOL power and the required orientation of the implant in the eye to correct the astigmatism successfully.
Toric IOLs have special markers on the peripheral parts of the lens that enable the surgeon to see the orientation of the astigmatism correction in the lens. Once the toric IOL is implanted in the eye, the surgeon then rotates the lens so the astigmatism correction is properly aligned for best results.
Use of a toric IOL during cataract surgery does not increase the risk of common cataract surgery complications, but a misaligned toric IOL can cause blurred vision that cannot easily be corrected with eyeglasses or contact lenses.
Brands of toric IOLs include AcrySof IQ Toric IOL (Alcon) and Tecnis Toric Aspheric IOL (Abbott Medical Optics).
Excellent Toric IOL Outcomes
Research has shown that toric lenses produce excellent visual results after cataract surgery and can correct astigmatism more effectively than limbal relaxing incisions.
One study found that 94 percent of astigmatic eyes treated with toric lens implants had 0.50 D or less astigmatism and 98 percent had 0.75 D or less residual astigmatism after surgery, enabling people to see acceptably well without glasses or contact lenses.
And studies evaluating patient satisfaction after cataract surgery have found the majority of patients receiving toric IOLs are highly satisfied with their vision after surgery. One study found 92 percent of patients report no difficulty with driving at night without eyeglasses six months after surgery, and 97 percent of patients receiving toric lens implants would choose the same IOL to be implanted again.
Cost Of Toric IOLs
One reason that more people aren't opting for toric lens implants to reduce astigmatism after cataract surgery is the added cost of toric IOLs.
Though cataract surgery usually is fully covered by Medicare and all other medical insurance plans, the added costs associated with premium lens implants such as toric IOLs are an out-of-pocket expense that is the patient's responsibility.
If you choose a toric IOL to correct your astigmatism with cataract surgery, you can expect to pay an average of $1,310 per eye, according to a 2015 survey of U.S. eye surgeons by a leading industry analyst. By comparison, an LRI procedure to correct astigmatism will cost you an average of $584 per eye. Another option — arc-shaped incisions with a femtosecond laser (a modern, automated LRI-like astigmatism correction procedure) — has an average price of $1,136 per eye.
Another factor of why the use of toric IOLs is not as prevalent as it could be is that properly implanting a toric IOL is more challenging for cataract surgeons than using a conventional (spherical) IOL that's not designed for astigmatism correction surgery.
To correct astigmatism effectively, a toric IOL has to be positioned precisely within the eye, with the astigmatism correction aligned perfectly with the astigmatism present in the eye. Also, the toric IOL must be securely positioned so it does not rotate after it is implanted. Even small errors in the positioning of a toric IOL may significantly affect visual acuity after surgery — more so than they would with a spherical IOL.
Ask Your Cataract Surgeon
If you have astigmatism and need cataract surgery, ask your eye doctor to refer you to a cataract surgeon who embraces the latest surgical technology, including toric IOLs.
During your consultation prior to surgery, your surgeon will discuss with you the best options for your particular needs so you can be less dependent on eyeglasses after your cataracts are removed.
Five reasons why toric IOLs are the best choice for managing astigmatism. Ophthalmology Times.April 2016.
Market Scope 2015 Survey of Cataract and Refractive Surgeons. Market Scope LLC.
Correction of low corneal astigmatism in cataract surgery. International Journal of Ophthalmology. August 2015.
Modern management of astigmatism. International Ophthalmology Clinics. Winter 2013.
Visual function and patient experience after bilateral implantation of toric intraocular lenses. Journal of Cataract & Refractive Surgery. April 2010.
Comparison of clinical and patient-reported outcomes with bilateral AcrySof toric or spherical control intraocular lenses. Journal of Refractive Surgery. October 2009.
Page published in February 2019
Page updated in November 2021