...continued
from Which LASIK Laser Is Best?
Types of Modern Excimer Lasers Used for LASIK
Slit scanning lasers Slit scanning lasers use relatively small beams linked to a rotational device with slit holes that
enlarge. The laser beams scan across these holes during surgery, producing a gradually enlarging
ablation zone. The approach provides a uniform beam and, potentially,
smoother ablations than now obsolete broad-beam lasers. The disadvantages include a slightly greater risk of
decentration and overcorrection.
Spot scanning lasers Spot scanning (or "flying-spot") lasers, which are the most common, utilize small-diameter
laser beams (from 0.8 to 2 mm) scanned across the cornea to produce
the ablation zone. This approach has the potential to produce the smoothest ablations, to more readily allow customized ablations, and to
better treat irregular astigmatism.
Wavefront-guided lasers Many excimer lasers are connected to a device that detects and "maps" defects in the eye's optical system,
based on how light waves travel through the eye. These wavefront
devices individually guide the way the eye's cornea is reshaped to achieve a custom ablation. [See also:
Wavefront or Custom LASIK]
Excimer Lasers and Eye Tracking
Most modern excimer lasers now have automated eye tracking systems to keep the laser beam on target. Studies have demonstrated
that eye trackers produce better outcomes, compared with lasers that in the past did not use eye tracking systems. [For more information,
read about LASIK risks.]
Indications and Features of Excimer Lasers
In the following chart, OZ stands for optical zone, meaning the maximum size of the pupil allowing light to pass through
the eye that can effectively be targeted for correction with a specific laser. TZ stands for the maximum treatment area, including
a transition zone that can be used in an ablation to achieve vision correction in the targeted area.
Modern FDA-Approved Excimer Lasers
| Model |
Indication |
Type of Laser Beam |
Optical Zone (OZ) and Treatment Zone (TZ) |
FDA Approval Year |
Alcon LADARVision 4000 & CustomCornea (laser plus wavefront device to guide laser) |
Myopia: up to -8.00 D with or without astigmatism (up to -4.00 D)
Hyperopia and hyperopic astigmatism: up to +5.00 D (near vision problems) and astigmatism causing distance vision problems up to -3.00 D |
Scanning spot (0.8 mm) |
OZ: 5.5 mm
TZ: 7.5 mm |
2002 (myopia with or without astigmatism)
2006 (hyperopia and hyperopic astigmatism) |
Alcon LADAR6000 & CustomCornea (laser plus wavefront device to guide laser) |
Same as LADARVision 4000 |
Same as LADARVision 4000 |
OZ: 6.5 mm
TZ: 9.0 mm |
2006 (flexible platform and faster than previous models) |
Bausch & Lomb Technolas 217A and Technolas 217z Zyoptix (laser plus wavefront device to guide laser, approved 2003) |
Myopia: up to -12.00 D with or without astigmatism (up to -3.00 D) Hyperopia: up to +4.00 D with or without astigmatism (up to +2.00 D) |
Scanning spot (2.0 mm) |
OZ: 6.0 mm
TZ: 7.0 mm |
2000 (myopia from -1.00 to -7.00 D) 2002 (myopia up to -11.00 D) 2003 (hyperopia with or without mixed astigmatism) |
Carl Zeiss Meditec MEL 80 |
Myopia: up to -7.00 D with or without astigmatism (up to -3.00 D) |
Scanning spot (0.7 mm) Gaussian profile with more energy applied centrally |
OZ: 6.0 to 7.0 mm
TZ: 7.7 to 8.9 mm |
2006 (myopia with or without astigmatism) |
| Nidek EC-5000 |
Myopia: -1.00 to -14.00 D with or without astigmatism (less than 4.00 D) Hyperopia: +0.50 to +5.00 D and up to +2.00 D astigmatism |
Scanning slit (7.0 x 2.0 mm) |
OZ: 5.5 mm
TZ: 7.0 mm |
2000 (myopia from -1.00 to -14.00 D) 2006 (hyperopia and hyperopic astigmatism) |
Visx Star S4 & WaveScan WaveFront System (laser plus wavefront device to guide laser) |
Myopia: up to -6.00 D with or without astigmatism (up to -3.00 D) |
Variable scanning spot beam (0.65 mm to 6.5 mm) |
OZ: 4.0 to 9.0 mm
TZ: 4.5 to 9.5 mm |
2003 |
Visx Star S4 IR & CustomVue (laser plus wavefront device to guide laser) |
Myopia: up to -6.00 D with or without astigmatism (up to -3.00 D)
Hyperopia: up to +3.00 D and up to +2.00 D of astigmatism
Mixed astigmatism: up to 5.00 D |
Same as S4 |
OZ: 6.0 mm
TZ: 9.0 mm |
2005 |
WaveLight Allegretto Wave |
Myopia: up to -12.00 D with or without astigmatism (up to -6.00 D)
Hyperopia: up to +6.00 D with or without astigmatism (up to +5.00 D, not exceeding mean spherical equivalent or total refractive error of +6.00 D)
Mixed astigmatism: up to 6.00 D |
Scanning spot beam (0.95 mm) with emphasis on applying more energy centrally (Gaussian profile) |
OZ: 4.5 to 8.0 mm TZ: 5.2 to 8.7 mm for spherical treatments; 7.0 to 9.0 mm for cylindrical and spherico- cylindrical treatments |
2003 (myopia and hyperopia)
2006 (mixed astigmatism) |
WaveLight Allegretto Wave With Allegro Analyzer (laser plus wavefront device to guide laser) |
Myopia: up to -7.00 D with or without astigmatism (up to 3.00 D)
Mixed astigmatism: up to 6.00 D |
Same as Allegretto Wave |
OZ: Same as Allegretto Wave TZ: Same as Allegretto Wave |
2006 2007 (mixed astigmatism) |
Notes: "D" is an abbreviation for "diopters."
While FDA approval is based on studies with these levels of diopters, individual
doctors are free to use their own discretion in deciding what is best for their patients. For example, a doctor may
choose to use a laser for a patient whose vision falls outside the above ranges, or may decide against using any
laser on a patient with -13.50 diopters of myopia, even though some are approved for up to -14.00. It is important that
patients and doctors discuss the risks and benefits before surgery is performed. |
Pupil Size, Ablation Speed, and Patient Comfort
In recent years, increasing evidence has indicated that the zone where laser energy is applied to reshape the eye during LASIK may be
too small to accommodate larger pupil sizes. If the pupil expands
in low light beyond the zone where the eye was reshaped (ablated) for vision correction, then vision problems such as glare and haloes
at night might occur.
Some surgeons believe that the diameter of the zone where laser energy is used (ablation zone) should be at least equal to the diameter
of your pupil in dim light. If you have larger pupils, the type of excimer laser used may be important in relation to how large of an
optical zone the machine is capable of creating. You should discuss this with your surgeon.
Ablation times also can differ among different lasers, ranging from 30 seconds to 60 seconds or longer. That may be important to you
in terms of your comfort as you undergo a procedure. Even the sounds the lasers make can differ, and may be something about which you
should ask your eye surgeon. You might also want to ask whether your surgeon uses a laser or a bladed instrument
(microkeratome) to create the flap used in LASIK eye surgery,
and how these two approaches might differ in terms of your comfort. [See also: Blade vs. Bladeless LASIK Debate]
Again, no matter which laser is used, remember that ultimately the skill and experience of your eye surgeon likely will be the most
important factors affecting the outcome of
your LASIK procedure.
[Page updated April 2007]
More articles on LASIK & other vision surgery: |
|